You have to feel sorry for Democrats, what with 200 of their elected offcials switching parties since Clinton was elected and almost no Republicans returning the compliment. So it’s not surprising that Frank Rich rushed to embrace Tanya Melich and her “profusely documented, tell-all account,” The Republican War Against Women: An Insider’s Report from Behind the Lines (Bantam, 356 pages, $ 23.95). Rich and others who champion this book, however, face a wee problem: The documentation is shoddy and high- ly selective, the tales that get told are so flagrantly revisionist that even a political amateur would smirk, the premise depends on Orwellian doublespeak, and the “insider” simply isn’t. In short, this is not a serious book making a legitimate argument. Nor is it a true insider’s account with genuine revelations and fresh information. Rather, it is a screed, a long whine, with the intellectual depth of a wading pool.
Start with the word “misogynist,” which appears nearly 70 times in one form or another, for an average of once every four page. Silly you if you thought it meant someone who hates or distrusts women. No, here a “misogynist” is anyone who disagrees with the liberal eral policies Melich advocates. Equally original is Melich’s standard for gauging the Republican party’s “assault on women.” It takes no account of real gains by women in the party hierarchy, but only measures gains by the right kind of woman — the pro-choice kind. And even the appointment of the right kind of woman doesn’t quite count for Melich unless the women in question are “placed in a position to affect reproductive health policy.” It’s rather like calling the Democratic party racist, with racist redefined to mean anything Thomas Sowell would disagree with, and racist behavior the appointment of anyone other than black individuals, who hold Sowell’s views, to positions responsible for race- related matters.