As if America isn’t going through enough already, here’s a news flash: Our nation is to blame for propagating the story that Marco Polo introduced pasta to Italy from China. This “persistent” whopper was, in no uncertain terms, “conjured up by the Americans,” writes Kantha Shelke. In 1929, an American trade magazine, then called Macaroni Journal, ran an ad depicting Marco Polo in the China Sea with an Italian crew including a sailor named Macaroni. The fine fellow comes ashore with tales of women making strings of dough—and Polo names the product for him.
“The story inspired countless advertisements, restaurant placemats, cookbooks and even movies, and the tongue-in-cheek advertisement turned into a seemingly unshakeable legend,” writes Shelke in this engaging entry in Reaktion Books’ Edible Series. By bursting this delicious dumpling, Shelke is also making a larger contention: Pasta and noodles developed in “different but complementary culinary traditions.” No wet-noodle argument here. This debate is apparently hotter than Shrimp Fra Diavolo: “Unlike the works of other writers, there will be no attempt in this book to link the two culinary realms.”