How to improve Obama’s ethics and lobbying executive order

Published



President Barack Obama’s effort to eliminate the corrupting influence of special interests should be applauded, but it needs some refinement.

 

On his first full day in office, Obama issued an executive order on ethics that places restrictions on lobbyists who transition to government service. 

 

On March 20, the president issued a memo on the dispensation of Recovery Act money. Under this memo, lobbyist communications about specific Recovery Act spending must be made in writing; no in-person meetings are permitted.

 

Oral communications with lobbyists about general Recovery Act policies are permitted, but federal employees must document and post records of the communications to the Web within three business days. 

 

At one level, this sounds good: clean up government and get special interests under control. The problem is that not all lobbying is corrupt, and not all corrupt activities are lobbying. The objective should be to eliminate the corrupting influence money plays in politics, but the well intentioned Obama policies don’t quite hit the nail on the head.

 

They cast the net too broadly, capturing too many types of lobbying activities that should be encouraged, not discouraged.  At the same time, they miss too many things. Why should the lobbyist for a major defense contractor be prohibited from serving in government while the lobbyist’s boss, who may not be a “lobbyist,” is permitted to serve?

 

Why should a federally registered lobbyist be limited in forms of communication on the Recovery Act while a state registered lobbyist or a non-lobbyist would have no restrictions?

 

When it comes to lobbying in the public interest – that is, promoting policy changes that are not guided by profit motives – the Obama policies are having adverse unintended consequences. They are quashing, instead of encouraging, democratic participation.

 

They are making it more difficult for the Obama administration to attract the best and the brightest. And they are causing less disclosure – instead of more – as more and more people seek to deregister under the Lobbying Disclosure Act (LDA), the statute that defines who is a federal lobbyist.

 

The problem of casting the net too widely can be fixed with White House guidance on implementation of the executive order and with clearer messages from the president. Here are four steps the president can take to address the problem. 

  • The president should take aim at the corrupting influence of money. By honing his message and focusing on the influence of money in policymaking, the president can distinguish between public interest lobbying and other types of lobbying.

 The president should provide guidance to agencies on what is meant by executive branch lobbying. This definition should focus heavily on communications aimed at winning contracts and other financial awards from the federal government.
 

Restricting speech must be avoided while disclosure should be emphasized. Regardless of whether a lobbyist or not, an individual should disclose attempts to influence executive branch officials when it comes to how money is spent. This avoids the unfair lobbying policy regarding the Recovery Act and helps the public better understand the influence of special interests.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.