Since arriving on the scene in 2008, psephologist Nate Silver has been widely hailed as a “statistics guru.” That phrase is a good fit for what Silver does. While his writing style often mimics the technical wonkery one sees in political science journals, his work differs from science in important ways. One big difference is that scientific work is supposed to be replicable. Though he dedicates a great many words to his methodology, Silver rarely provides enough details to enable the industrious skeptic to reproduce and critique it.
This is not a criticism, per se. A blog at the New York Times is quite different than a scholarly article in the Journal of Politics. The point is that: with Silver, it comes down to trust. Do you trust that he is ahead of the curve, that he has plucked an insight out of the data that others have missed?