The politics of Democratic opposition to Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito were twofold. One, 2006 was an election year, and senators in the minority were hearing about it from their base. Two, partisanship, a vessel for the Senate filibuster, had dropped anchor inside the confirmation process. Using a procedural tool to stymie a nominee was not unusual, but rather the emerging norm.
Sen. Dianne Feinstein became plenty aware of both in a matter of weeks that January. Now the ranking member on the Senate Judiciary Committee, her name was on the ballot in California, but she wasn’t eager to run to her left despite a war-weary and energized grassroots. Ten days out from a committee vote on Alito’s nomination, she remarked—”candidly”—she didn’t see the need to prevent the judge from receiving an up-or-down vote.