Coinciding with and probably as a result of the McChrystal firing, a lot of questioning has been directed toward the Obama administration about its previously announced decision to begin the withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan in July of 2011. That was originally announced by the President when he outlined his new strategy about a year ago. Since then, as administration officials have been questioned about the date, mixed messages have been the result. VP Joe Biden has said the date is “firm”. SecDef Robert Gates has said it would be based on “conditions on the ground.”
Critics have rightfully said that announcing a firm withdrawal date is a strategically self-defeating move. It gives the enemy a finish line they simply have to survive long enough to make. In addition, it isn’t great for the morale of those US soldiers fighting there now.