Echoing a report issued last month from the Kaiser Family Foundation, Ezra Klein says that the projections of significant adverse selection in the Obamacare exchange pools are vastly overblown. Indeed, Klein even claims that “the risk of a ‘death spiral’ is over.” But a closer look at Klein’s reasoning—laid out in an eleven-point blog post—should leave readers unconvinced.
Enrollment data show that the composition of Obamacare enrollees is older than the Obama administration and the health care law’s backers had anticipated, a point that Klein concedes. Faced with this fact, Klein tries to persuade readers—and perhaps even himself—that the health status of enrollees, not age, is a more telling predictor of an insurance pool’s viability. Quoting the report from Kaiser, Klein repeats, “[T]he health mix of ACA enrollment is much more important than the age mix.” That may well be true. But the enrollment data suggest that the health mix in the Obamacare exchange pools is far from ideal.