It would appear that Lindsay Lohan loves to keep us guessing. The starlet won’t come right out — no pun intended — and discuss her much-speculated-about relationship with Samantha Ronson. But between their matching tattoos, talk of house-hunting and a bauble spotted on a certain finger, inquiring minds have concluded they must be a couple.

LiLo recently showed off a new star tattoo to a Marie Claire reporter, saying, “Samantha has a bunch of stars, so I got that” — then pointed out a heart tattoo and added, “She got this.” (She also mentioned that she’s looking for a house “with someone.” Mm-hmm.)