And if you win you’ll get this shiney fiddle made of gold,
But if you lose the devil gets your soul
– Charlie Daniels Band
Google’s recent decision to stop participating in Chinese censorship, as well as all the dithering leading up to it, is perhaps not unexpected. China is a one-party state that is in the business of information control. Google is the business of information access. How long would it be before these visions collided? There is plenty of chatter out there on the subject, but I want to take a step back from it for a moment, if but to wrestle with the intractability of this and similar situations. In short, I want to talk about a brave new world in which companies are having increasingly to do business with the devil (read: government).