It is said that Captain America is the moral compass of the Marvel Universe, the standard of virtue against which all other heroes should be measured. To give a sense of the purity of his heart and conscience, it is best to quote him directly. “This land of ours may have seen some hard times” he says in issue #255 (March 1981), “and maybe it hasn’t always lived up to the promise of the Founding Fathers . . . but America at its best has always stood for the rights of man, and against the rule of tyrants! And if America needs a man to stand for her principles, to battle the forces of tyranny—then, as God is my witness, I shall be that man!” And from issue #273 (September 1982), this is the sort of thing he tells his foes—in this case, agents of HYDRA: “Like every other tyrant, your lust for power masks your true motive—fear of a free society! For, with freedom, man has pride, dignity, and a sense of destiny. Your fear causes you to arrogantly mock those concepts! You seek to reduce mankind to your own level! But against every despot there has always arisen a champion of liberty! That is why I exist—and why men like me shall always win!”
But what are Captain America’s politics? One might expect him to be voted “Most Likely to Be a Conservative” in the superhero yearbook. He comes to us from the past, bringing old-timey morals and manners from a generation before hippies and the pill. He has old-fashioned ideas regarding patriotic duty and sacrifice, decency and formality, hard work, loyalty and integrity. As “a man out of time,” his stories can be critical of our lives today, but from a perspective within our own cultural context; a perspective that is outmoded but not quite obsolete. Having lived through the 1930s and 40s, however, Cap’s view of those times isn’t romantic or nostalgic; he knows that the past was not unqualifiedly great and can see how we have both declined and progressed since then.