Marshalling Precedent: With Nod to Predecessor, Roberts Affirms Mandate

Published



In September 2009, President Obama disagreed vehemently with the notion that the Affordable Care Act’s individual mandate was a tax: “A responsibility to get health insurance is not a tax increase,” he told George Stephanopolous. And even on the eve of oral argument, the president’s Office of Management and Budget told Congress that the mandate was not a tax.

Nevertheless, the Justice Department made precisely the opposite argument in the federal courts, and that argument ultimately persuaded the Supreme Court. Today, the Court held that the individual mandate is a lawful exercise of the Constitution’s tax power.

Full midterm coverage.Deeper analysis.

Get unlimited access to Washington Examiner's reporting, expert analysis, and coverage of the midterm elections.

Get Unlimited Access

Cancel anytime.