The Folly of Excusing FDR on the Holocaust

Published



During the Holocaust, the Roosevelt administration claimed that rescuing Jews was too difficult, bombing Auschwitz was impractical, and even if the president wanted to help, his hands were tied by Congress and public opinion. Now two young historians are making many of the same excuses. These excuses were untenable then, and the passage of time has made them no more credible.

Rebecca Erbelding’s Rescue Board, her first book, focuses on the War Refugee Board, a small U.S. government agency created in 1944 to save Jews from the Nazis. The main achievements of the board have been chronicled by many previous scholars since the late 1960s. Erbelding adds more details to the story, but more trees do not always make it easier to see the forest. She thinks it germane to point out, for example, that one of the board’s emissaries “always wore a white shirt; he abhorred colored ones,” and that another was “at most, one-sixteenth Jewish,” rather than half-Jewish as rumors had it. Needless to say, such trivia serves to clutter rather than illuminate the larger story. Erbelding’s penchant for piling on irrelevant details is, however, the least of her book’s flaws.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.