University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth Professor Lucas Mann recently argued in a piece for Slate that he has “never seen classrooms like mine in the pages of the Times” and notes that he sees students struggling with finding their voices and certainly not out of “some sense of political fear and self-silencing.” Mann’s experience as a professor at a regional school in southern Massachusetts and not an elite, national research university is one where his “students work really hard to make others feel welcome because they’re going through the same process. They are, by and large, far gentler with one another’s ideas than their own.” In short, Mann is suggesting that the press and national zeitgeist is focused on a few dozen elite schools which enroll a few hundred-thousand students and not the millions who are enrolled elsewhere in over 5,000 other colleges and universities.
Professor Mann is absolutely correct in drawing some real distinctions about the nation’s elite schools, but he is too quick to dismiss the threat of cancel culture as an elite phenomenon and focuses on his particular classrooms and not the trials and tribulations outside classroom settings. The sad reality is that cancel culture and the fear of speaking up runs rampant on our college campuses, and viewpoint diversity is no longer considered a sacred, core value in higher education—albeit to different degrees across varied institutions of higher education. Students who attend the nation’s elite schools—those that purportedly thrive in the world of research, innovation and discovery—are actually more likely to try to cancel speech than their peers who attend lower-ranked educational institutions.