Franken-Coleman State Supreme Court Case Set for June 1

Published



As they like to say in Minnesota, uff-da this sure has been a long recount, and it just got a little longer. Oral arguments for the supreme court appeal will begin on June 1, which is later than the Franken campaign requested. So there won’t be a Senator Franken until this summer at the earliest. Shucks. Franken currently leads Coleman by 312 votes. I doubt that Coleman will be able to make up the difference in his appeal, which rests mainly on the argument that there were different standards used to count absentee ballots, and, therefore on equal protection grounds the court needs to count roughly an additional 4,000 rejected ballots. The first problem is that the supreme court is unlikely to rule in Coleman’s favor. Aside from the substantive arguments against Coleman’s appeal, Coleman isn’t facing an unbiased court. Two Republican-appointed justices have recused themselves. In what appears to have been a masterful stroke of simple partisan genius, the Democratic secretary of state Mark Ritchie chose these two justices and two left-leaning lower court judges to count disputed ballots in December. The ballot-counting was mostly fair, but Ritchie certainly must have known that the Republican appointees would have to recuse themselves during any appeals thereafter.So, the case will be heard by the same five justices whose rulings are partly to blame for the use of different methods of counting rejected absentee ballots. In December, rather than waiting until the election contest to settle the dispute over counting these ballots, the supreme court ruled:

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.