The Fall 2016 issue of the Claremont Review of Books features a review well worth your time by Jeremy Rabkin, a professor at the splendidly named Antonin Scalia Law School (previously the George Mason University Law School). The professor has written on Randy Barnett’s new book, Our Republican Constitution: Securing the Liberty and Sovereignty of We the People. We should add that anything Rabkin or Barnett writes is well worth reading, whether you agree with them or not. (Both have written for THE WEEKLY STANDARD.)
As Rabkin shows, Barnett is an activist for constitutional liberty and limited government. When the debate over the constitutionality of Obamacare intensified, most commentators thought the law would survive any imaginable constitutional challenge. Barnett, a law professor at Georgetown, dissented. What about the commerce clause, which gives Congress power to regulate commerce among the several states? Does not the requirement that we all must buy health insurance violate that clause? Barnett helped represent the National Federation of Independent Businesses in its challenge to the health care law, and five Justices agreed with the group. “Congress has never before attempted to use the commerce power to order individuals not engaged in commerce to buy an unwanted product”—in this case health insurance—and “nothing in the text to the Constitution suggests it can.”