Judge Gorsuch’s Back-Seat Drivers

Published



“Hard cases,” it’s often said, “make bad law.” They also make for bad legal commentary, especially in the week of a Supreme Court confirmation hearing, where a nominee’s critics try to fault him for failing to side with sympathetic litigants—even when the judge was just following the laws that Congress wrote. We’ve seen some of that this week during the Gorsuch hearings. The judge’s critics have seized upon his position in TransAm Trucking v. Department of Labor, a 2016 decision involving a very unfortunate incident.

Alphonse Maddin, a truck driver, was hauling a trailer down I-88 in Illinois in the middle of the night, in January 2009, when (in the court’s majority opinion’s words) “the brakes on his trailer froze because of subzero temperatures.” Maddin pulled off the road when he ran low on gas and couldn’t find a gas station, and when he tried to get back on the road he found that his trailer’s brakes had frozen.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.