The Kindest Cut

Published



AS THE NEW ACADEMIC YEAR BEGINS, parents will give, as they always do, lectures about studying hard and attending class. But nonetheless many collegians will devote time to chugging pints, throwing darts, and doing just about anything that doesn’t involve cracking the books. This seems a gross waste of resources, but, considering the often ridiculous content of those neglected textbooks and ignored lectures, some of these prodigal students just might be better off.

This may seem a sinister suggestion, but even the scholarly John Henry Newman–not one to spend much time away from the books–made a similar suggestion in the 19th century: The young men of his day, he wrote, would benefit more from a university that required nothing of its students at all–simply bringing them together in revelry for four years–than from one that, omitting residential and academic oversight, awarded degrees to anyone who could pass tests on a scattered array of subjects. At least then they would be graduated without their minds having been contorted by an inundation of random crumbs of knowledge.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.