Simple logic suggests that it’s better to have more votes than fewer. A larger caucus makes it easier to push legislation and allows certain members to defect from their party in the face of constituent opposition or re-election considerations. The conventional wisdom coming out of the 2010 midterms has been that Democrats will have a harder time passing their agenda. Obviously, the House is no longer under their control, and the loss of six Senate seats, it seems, bolsters the hand of Mitch McConnell and his Republican ranks. Counter-intuitively, however, there is reason to wonder whether Harry Reid and Senate Democrats will have an easier time legislating in the 112th Congress than they did in the 111th.
When the Democrats came into the last Congress, bolstered by gains in the 2008 elections, they possessed majorities larger than either party had enjoyed in recent years. With President Obama in the White House, pundits were anticipating a New Deal-like wave of policy that would quickly move through the Congress, producing the “change” that voters seemed to be clamoring for. We now know that things didn’t quite work out so easily for Democrats, especially on the Senate side. The reality, which few liberals seemed to recognize at the time, was that the Senate was being asked to play a role for which it is unsuited—that of a swift, efficient, legislative body. Ironically, with Democrats possessing the magical 60 votes to cut off Republican filibusters—and then 59 seats after the election of Massachusetts Republican Scott Brown—a dynamic soon developed that actually made legislating much more tedious and unpredictable. A big majority did not guarantee success.