It is no secret that the environmental movement is trying to do to coal what it did 35 years ago to nuclear power — kill it off entirely in the name of saving the planet. The surprise is that fossil fuel energy producers and some Republican politicians seem intent on helping them. Not content to let the marketplace guide decisions about what fuel sources our electric utilities should use, some natural gas interests are aligning with environmentalists to press for “incentives,” regulations and mandates for fuelswitching from coal to natural gas. It is a classic case of what economist Bruce Yandle calls a “bootleggers and Baptists” coalition. In dry counties in the Bible Belt, Yandle explains, bootleggers who depend on their wares remaining illegal to make a profit would support the Baptist politicians who voted to keep alcohol illegal.
In the case of energy, natural gas interests are happily fulfilling the bootlegger role to the environmental fundamentalists who demand low-carbon moral purity from our energy supply.