For the past decade, the Bowl Championship Series unfailingly provided the matchup for college football’s national title game that reflected the public consensus. (In the six years prior to that, the BCS’s record was spottier, but after 2003-04, its formula was wisely streamlined, and its subsequent results were impeccable.) This year, that BCS selection process, which involved 167 polls voters and six computer rankings (one of which was the Anderson & Hester Rankings, which Chris Hester and I co-created), was replaced by a subjective committee of 13 people. And in its penultimate rankings of the season, the committee has now declared that Florida State, which is the nation’s sole unbeaten team and has more 1st-place votes in the A.P. poll than any other squad, wouldn’t get to play in the national championship game if the committee were deciding such things. In fact, the committee doesn’t even rank Florida State third, instead relegating the undefeated Seminoles to fourth, behind three 1-loss teams (Alabama, Oregon, and TCU).
Thankfully, there is a 4-team playoff this year, which gives the committee the margin of error it seemingly needs.