Historical analogies are the last refuge of politicians seeking to justify a policy indefensible on its own merits. Such is the case when it comes to determining policies towards prospective Muslim immigrants. Proponents of allowing these refugees into the country are in difficulty. It seems (1) that the FBI says they cannot be vetted properly because of the destruction of records in Syria and other war-torn countries, (2) terrorists have infiltrated the ranks of refugees in other countries and may well do so here, (3) if even a small number of such terrorists pass through our imperfect filter, they can kill and maim thousands before being apprehended, and recruit others to their cause.
In the face of those facts, proponents of accepting Muslim immigrants liken pleas to close our borders to them to, first, the decision to turn away Jewish immigrants fleeing the death camps of Europe, and second, to the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II. Neither of those is even by the wildest stretch of imagination analogous to the problem created by Muslim immigrants seeking entry here.