Sebelius and Holder Admit that Obamacare is Fundamentally About Coercion

Published



The Washington Post’s Ezra Klein and the New Republic’s Jonathan Chait, two men who believe as an article of faith that government-run health care is the irresistible wave of the future, claim that they aren’t fazed by this week’s federal district court ruling declaring Obamacare’s (in the words of the New York Times) “keystone provision” unconstitutional. Both say that work-arounds could be designed to allow Obamacare to function without the mandate. But in addition to being problematic from a legal and policy perspective, any such efforts to save Obamacare would presumably require subsequent legislation, which almost certainly wouldn’t pass. Moreover, Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius and Attorney General Eric Holder disagree with Klein and Chait.

Immediately following the federal court ruling, Sebelius and Holder wrote in the Washington Post that a ruling declaring the individual mandate unconstitutional—should the ruling hold up on appeal—”would have devastating consequences.” In their piece, they disingenuously refer to the mandate as a requirement that Americans buy “basic health coverage.” In reality, it is a requirement that Americans buy federally approved health coverage, which—as the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has noted in projecting that Americans’ premiums would rise—would be anything but basic. Regardless, Sebelius and Holder maintain that, without the individual mandate, “Premiums would skyrocket” and “coverage would be unaffordable.” Without the individual mandate, they conclude, “controlling costs and ending discrimination against people with preexisting conditions doesn’t work.” 

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.