Obamacare and the Perils of Narrow Majorities

Published



As the Republican alternative to Obamacare winds its tortuous way through Congress, the parallels with the big mistake President Barack Obama and congressional Democrats made eight years ago are unmistakable. Such large changes to society should only be done with a broad coalition, otherwise they risk being undermined by our very system of government.

The grand bargain at the heart of America’s constitutional system is consensus yields power. After years of unfair treatment at the hands of King George III and Parliament, the young republic was understandably hesitant to centralize governing authority. It was only due to the many crises of the 1780s—unmanageable public debt, interstate rivalries, foreign interference, and civil unrest—that Americans decided to empower a national government. But there was a catch: Our government would be capable of doing many great things, but only when a broad segment of society agreed on the actions. By widely separating powers, the Framers effectively created a diverse array of veto points where social groups that felt their rights were about to be infringed could organize to stop the government in its tracks.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.