The Supreme Court will hear a case over whether Alaska imposed an unconstitutional excessive fine by seizing a man’s plane after he errantly transported a six-pack of beer to a town that outlaws alcohol.
The high court said on Monday that it would take up arguments in Jouppi v. Alaska for its upcoming term. The case deals with whether Kenneth Jouppi’s Eighth Amendment rights were violated when the state seized his $95,000 plane after one of his passengers brought a six-pack of Budweiser into a village where it is unlawful to have alcohol. Jouppi’s lawyers asked the high court whether the excessive fines clause of the Eighth Amendment requires a court to look at the “gravity of the underlying offense purely in the abstract or should consider the gravity of the specific defendant’s wrongdoing.”