Now that the blizzard of CYA leaks from anonymous McCain campaign staffers has slowed, it is possible to assess Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin in a dispassionate manner. First, some facts, beginning with the clearly positive affect of her selection as the Republican vice-presidential nominee on John McCain’s 2008 presidential effort. As The Wall Street Journal’s Blake Dvorak pointed out earlier this week, exit polling showed that 60 percent of voters said Palin was a factor in their decision, with 56 percent of them opting for McCain. On the other hand, 60 percent said she wasn’t qualified to be president. Normally, vice-presidential candidates barely make the needle move either way, but Palin’s selection undoubtedly injected an enthusiasm that McCain’s campaign desperately needed, fueling a three-point mid-September lead over Democrat Barack Obama just as the Wall Street economic crisis broke.
And that brings us to 2008’s pivotal political moment, McCain’s “suspension” of his campaign and disastrous return to Washington for two days of ineffectual attempts to play a lead role in resolving the economic crisis. Instead, McCain ended up Me-Too-ing Obama’s cautious support of the Bush-Paulson-Pelosi $700 billion Wall Street bailout, while adding another $300 billion mortgage aid proposal. With no real difference between the two presidential candidates on the key issue of the campaign’s closing weeks, most voters opted for making history by electing America’s first black chief executive. Absent Palin – plus a late boost from Joe the Plumber – McCain likely would have otherwise been relegated to Alf Landon status among GOP losers.