If ever there were an occasion for sober analysis from the political media, President Trump’s decision to fire FBI Director James Comey would be it. But in the immediate aftermath of that news, too many in the media used prominent platforms to issue sweeping conclusions — either informing their audiences that it was proof Trump was hampering an FBI investigation, or that the move was totally clean.
News of Comey’s firing broke on Tuesday evening, but before the day had ended, the editorial board of the New York Times declared with a low evidence-to-confidence ratio: “Mr. Comey was fired because he was leading an active investigation that could bring down a president.” On CNN, Jeffrey Toobin told viewers, “[Comey] was fired because he was investigating the White House.”