Hundreds of state and local governments have saved taxpayer dollars while delivering needed services more efficiently by having private companies handle everything from garbage pickup to welfare administration. But an obscure amendment to the House version of the pending farm bill could hobble such efforts. House-Senate negotiators racing to beat an April 18 deadline ought to scuttle the amendment and leave states free to decide for themselves how best to provide services.
Most immediately threatened is the Food Stamp program, which is run by the states with money provided through the Department of Agriculture. Current regulations require that ultimate “certification” of a recipient’s eligibility be conducted only by a state employee. Fine. The amendment, by Rep. Joe Baca, D-Calif., would extend that bureaucratic monopoly to “any official communications with a prospective applicant.” In short, states would not be free to pay private firms to administer Food Stamp services. Even nonprofits would be excluded. The Baca amendment is disguised as a quality-control requirement. But it would prevent states from taking advantage of competitive bidding, more flexible labor arrangements and technological advances that are more easily implemented in the dynamic private sector than in rule-bound state bureaucracies. (No wonder public employee unions are enthusiastically backing Baca.)