President Trump is reportedly considering using his emergency powers to intervene in electricity markets and prop up failing coal and nuclear power plants. Bloomberg reports that the plan would force utility companies to buy power from “fuel secure” coal and nuclear plants in order to stop their “premature retirement,” and the administration is further considering the creation of a “Strategic Electric Generation Reserve” like the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. Unfortunately, this policy threatens to impose numerous costs while offering no benefits.
The argument behind the proposal is that natural gas and renewable energy may struggle to provide electricity during extreme weather events, and that the market does not incentivize power companies sufficiently to maintain reliability.