Retired Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer is making the rounds in support of his new book released this week, Reading the Constitution: Why I Chose Pragmatism, Not Textualism. The subtitle really tells the story of the work. Breyer has written a volume critiquing the current Supreme Court majority’s approach to interpreting and applying the Constitution. In doing so, though, he has unintentionally exposed the weakness of his and other competing approaches.
By the time of his retirement in June 2022, Breyer consistently landed in the minority on significant decisions made by the court. This minority status showed decisively in the weeks leading up to his stepping down. The court closed up the 2021-2022 term by expanding Second Amendment protections, firming up religious liberty claims, and restricting the Environmental Protection Agency’s capacity to regulate. A mere six days before he left the bench, the justices handed down Dobbs v. Jackson, the case that overturned Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey. Breyer dissented from every one of those important decisions.