Keeping the votes honest

Published



There has been much discussion in New York since that state’s primary earlier this month about reports that voting machines there failed to record hundreds of votes cast for Barack Obama. We have editorialized many times in the past about the need for ballots to be recorded on paper, not just electronically, in all elections. We now note, though, that the Supreme Court is considering a case that raises a closely related issue – the potential for fraudulent votes to be cast and counted. In that case, some Indiana residents are challenging a state law requiring that people show photo IDs in order to vote. The law, the facts, common sense and basic fairness all argue in favor of the state law, and against its challengers.

Those who challenge the law cite 34 Indianapolis residents (out of 165,000 who voted) who were not allowed to cast ballots in last November’s mayoral race because they could not produce proper identification. But all 34, by state law, were afforded the chance to cast provisional ballots that would be counted if they could show a clerk proof of their identities within 10 days. Only two chose to bother doing so – and their votes were indeed counted. In short, nobody was disenfranchised by the law. The U.S. Constitution leaves it up to states to set the “times, places and manner” of holding elections, and Supreme Court precedent has affirmed that states can promulgate reasonable regulations to ensure the integrity of elections. It only makes sense to think that a simple photo ID requirement, the same as is required for airplane travel, would fall well within those regulatory parameters.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.