“Blue smoke and mirrors” is a particularly apt phrase to describe the way Washington politicians in both major parties create annual budget proposals. “Rosy scenario” is another. Call it what you will, healthy public policy cannot be based on fantasy foundations. To be sure, multiple assumptions about future economic and fiscal conditions must be made in constructing a forward-looking budget, but in doing so many opportunities are created for public policy mischief. Since professional politicians are at the helm, said mischief is almost always in the direction of creating a misleadingly positive outlook about the future as a tool for gaining support for more spending and debt in the present. Consider President Obama’s 2012 federal budget proposal in this context.
Rosy scenario certainly applies to the Obama budget’s assumptions about economic growth, unemployment, and inflation between now and 2013. The president’s proposal assumes real Gross Domestic Product growth of 3.1 percent this year, four percent next year and 4.5 percent the year after. To grasp the unreality of that projection, recall that in only four years of the past 30 has the economy grown four percent or more. Two of those years, 1983 (4.52 percent) and 1984 (7.19 percent), were at the outset of the economic boom sparked by President Reagan’s tax cuts. The other two years, 1997 (4.46 percent) and 1999 (4.83 percent), both followed on compromises between President Clinton and Republican congressional majorities that restrained federal spending and debt, and cut taxes. White House assertions to the contrary notwithstanding, the proposed Obama budget raises taxes, adds more debt and hikes federal spending.