By now, there have been plenty of takes pointing out the Death Star-sized plot holes and flaws in “Star Wars: The Last Jedi,” as well as the appalling character development. Though I agree with those points, for a film that fails on every level, it seems inadequate to just narrowly focus on the reasons why the movie is largely pointless and makes no sense. So given that I’m getting a late start, I’d want to add some thoughts on the movie’s failed attempt at some sort of pseudo-intellectual, postmodern, rumination on the Star Wars mythology.
In “The Last Jedi,” director Rian Johnson, while still borrowing a lot of the familiar tropes of Star Wars movies, also departs from the predictable fan service heavy approach of its predecessor “The Force Awakens.” By the end of its predecessor, which closely paralleled the first film in the original Star Wars trilogy, it seemed like the second one was set up to parallel the second in the original trilogy, with Rey training with Luke Skywalker in a remote location as Luke had trained with Yoda on Dagobah, and culminating with Rey figuring out her parentage in some way linked her to one of the other main characters. Instead, “The Last Jedi” veers off in multiple different directions, and Johnson basically toys with the audience and its expectations. It’s almost as if Johnson spent a few years reading a lot of Reddit threads and decided to play the role of the snarky commenter teasing fans and the innocence of the original movies.