A recent ruling by the notorious U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit provides President Trump an opportunity to strengthen our system of checks and balances. He should order federal lawyers to end their defense of a million-acre federal land lockup by the Obama administration and instead to acknowledge that the Property Clause gives Congress exclusive power over federal lands. Congress reasserted its unilateral power in 1976; and Obama’s land grab is unconstitutional, illegal, and ill-advised. Thus, Trump will restore constitutional equilibrium, ensure the uranium supply, and save jobs in the West.
The Property Clause gives Congress sole power to manage federal lands (“Congress shall have Power to dispose of and make all needful Rules and Regulations respecting the Territory or other Property belonging to the United States.”). Thus, the executive branch has only the power delegated by Congress. For almost 200 years, no single act defined the executive’s power over public lands; however, on occasion, Congress enacted legislation delegating the executive authority to withdraw federal lands.