Well, we have finally had a Republican presidential debate on foreign policy, and there were some surprises from the candidates.
Herman Cain came out with more specifics than he has on the few previous occasions when he has been asked questions on foreign policy. The candidate who didn’t seem to know that China is and has been for 47 years a nuclear power told us that there were nine—he resisted the temptation to say 9-9-9—nations with nuclear weapons and that Pakistan was one of them. He called for non-military assistance to the opposition in Iran. “A lot of clarity is missing” in our relationship with Pakistan: well, yes. But most of his responses were conclusory and not studded with revealing detail. He’d have multiple groups making recommendations to him and would consider all the facts and alternatives when making decisions. But he sowed a little confusion. He said he would trust the judgment of military leaders as to what is torture, but it is CIA not military interrogations that have been the subject of controversy, and when asked whether he would limit questioning to the Army Field Manual, as Barack Obama has, he replied that he did not consider waterboarding torture. Overall, I think his performance did not refute any previous impression that he would be over his head in dealing with military and foreign policy issues as president.