Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker is now a conservative hero after he both pushed his government union collective bargaining reform legislation through the Wisconsin Senate and then helped Republicans repel Democrat efforts to retake the Senate in recall elections. But when Walker first released his budget bill, many conservatives criticized Walker for exempting police and firefighters from his collective bargaining reforms. The concessions looked like a clear sacrifice of principle for the sake of political expediency. But Walker prevailed and few criticize him on those grounds today.
In Ohio last night, voters repealed Gov. John Kasich’s government union collective bargaining law by referendum before it could ever go into effect. Now a referendum on a single measure is different than state senate recall elections, but Kasich’s bill was clearly hurt by the overwhelming opposition from police and firefighter unions. Could the law have been saved if Kasich had exempted police and firefighters like Walker did? Probably not. But it at least would have been closer. The electorate that showed up in Ohio was not a liberal one. The same voters who rejected the government union reform bill also passed a referendum rejecting Obamacare’s individual mandate. This is a state looking for a moderate alternative to President Obama.