The Supreme Court’s unanimous decision to send the Little Sisters of the Poor case back to the courts below is a big victory for the Little Sisters and a big defeat for the Obama administration. So argues David French in National Review Online, and I agree. As French points out, an evenly split court could have left the Court of Appeals decision, in which case the government would have won and the Little Sisters lost.
The case concerns the application of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which requires a balancing of conscientious religious objection and obligations under laws. The Little Sisters here asserted that the government could have provided the object in view — free contraceptive coverage for the Little Sisters’ employees — without impinging on the Little Sisters’ conscientious objection to taking steps to facilitate provision of that coverage.