It’s been pretty widely assumed that the March 13 primaries in Alabama and Mississippi would be races between Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum. Gingrich has specifically targeted the two states, and has shied away from Saturday’s contest in Kansas, and Santorum has made it clear he’d like to beat Gingrich in the two states in the hopes of driving him from the race or at least from the public’s attention. Both counted on the apparent aversion of Southern voters for Mitt Romney, who in second place finishes won just 28% of the vote in South Carolina, Tennessee and Oklahoma and 26% in Georgia. Even as he was winning in Florida with 46% and Virginia (against only Ron Paul) with 60%, he ran below his statewide average in Southern-accented portions of those states. And he has been running below his statwide averages among white evangelical voters, who make up large majorities of the Alabama and Mississippi Republican electorates.
But, as Scott Conroy of Real Clear Politics argues, Romney’s Southern weakness may be overstated. Strong evidence of that comes in two polls in Alabama and one in Mississippi. When I saw the first of these, conducted March 1-6 for the Alabama Education Association, long the chief institutional support of the state’s Democratic party, I was skeptical. It showed Romney leading with 31% to 22% for Santorum and 21% for Gingrich. This seemed clearly out of line with the 2008 Alabama primary (41% for Mike Huckabee, 37% for John McCain, 18% for Romney) and out of line with the results of a March 1 Alabama State poll (23% for Santorum, 19% for Romney, 14% for Gingrich). But this morning Scott Rasmussen reported the results of a March 8 poll, showing Gingrich with 30%, Santorum with 29% and Romney with 28%–a three-way tie.