It has long been obvious that it’s not too hard to design a health-care plan that beats Obamacare. Nonpartisan scoring now finds that the House Republican health-care plan (released earlier this summer) would beat Obamacare in terms of reducing premiums, reducing federal spending, increasing access to doctors, and increasing the number of people with private health insurance, while Obamacare would beat the House GOP plan in terms of dumping huge numbers of people into Medicaid.
The nonpartisan Center for Health and Economy (H&E), co-chaired by liberal Princeton economist Uwe Reinhardt and center-right former Congressional Budget Office (CBO) Director Douglas Holtz-Eakin, conducted the scoring. The House GOP plan calls for non-income-tested, refundable tax credits for those who buy health insurance on their own, but it doesn’t specify the exact dollar values of those tax credits. H&E “assumed” that the dollar values would match those proposed in my Alternative to Obamacare (published by the Hudson Institute)—values that were originally proposed in the alternative released by the 2017 Project (which I ran) and were subsequently adopted in the alternatives put out by Virginia senate candidate Ed Gillespie, House Budget Committee Chairman Tom Price, and Wisconsin governor Scott Walker. These plans would all offer tax credits of $1,200 for those under 35 years of age, $2,100 for those between 35 and 50, and $3,000 for those 50 and over, plus $900 per child.