President Barack Obama’s Democratic allies in the U.S. Congress are taking only baby steps with his budget, putting off crucial decisions on his ambitious plans to expand health care, curb global warming and raise taxes on the wealthy.
Presidents Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton and both Bushes all got far stronger assists from Congress on their first budgets.
Recommended Stories
Nonetheless, Obama, is counting on votes approving budget outlines this week to give him some semblance of momentum.
“If we don’t pass the budget, it will empower those critics who don’t want to see anything getting done,” Obama told House Democrats Monday, according to a House aide who required anonymity to reveal what was said at the closed-door meeting.
Risk-averse Democrats, however, are merely kicking the can down the road rather than using the budget to give a real push to the president’s agenda.
On health care, global warming and even Obama’s signature “Making Work Pay” tax cut, the pending House and Senate budget plans offer no clues as to how those big ideas might advance.
The House and Senate are expected to pass separate versions of the budget resolution by week’s end, then reconcile differences after their spring break.
Budget resolutions are not law. They are not signed by the president. They are nonbinding outlines paving the way for future legislation. Often, they only determine the amount of money that can be spent on departments’ operating budgets that Congress must pass each year.
But they are an early measure of political strength. And especially in the first year of a presidency — when most of the heavy lifting is done on a president’s agenda — they have far more importance.
Votes taken during budget resolution debates can put members on record in favor of particular policies — tax cuts or increases, cost curbs on federal health care programs, or welfare reform, for example. Presidents use political capital in winning such votes, and the lawmakers casting them tend to buy into the ideas involved.
At a comparable stage in 1981, Ronald Reagan broke the back of the Democratic House leadership in winning a key budget vote in favor of his tax cut agenda.
And in 1993, debate on Bill Clinton’s deficit-cutting plan put his Democratic allies on record in support of higher taxes. That made subsequent votes to actually impose those tax increases easier.
Budget resolutions also ratified a key 1990 budget pact between President George H.W. Bush and Democrats in which Bush broke his “read my lips” pledge not to raise taxes.
Key Senate budget votes in 2001 and 2003 limited the size of George W. Bush’s tax cuts — but made sure they advanced.
To be sure, Obama’s plans for global warming and health care are still so fuzzy that it’s difficult to translate them into numbers in a congressional budget plan. And rather than muscle Republicans now, it could make sense for Democrats to hold off on detailed assumptions in hopes of building bipartisan consensus later.
Still, the budget proposal that Obama sent to Congress in February did present some difficult choices:
» Fewer itemized tax deductions for the wealthy, providing money to help buy health care insurance for tens of millions of Americans who do not have it.
» Cuts in government payments to insurance companies and health care providers.
» An expensive and highly controversial plan to combat global warming through a “cap-and-trade” scheme that calls for auctioning off pollution permits for nearly $650 billion.
The Senate, during budget debate Tuesday, voted to instead devote any revenues from the scheme to help consumers pay higher gasoline and electric bills that energy companies will pass on to them.
Both the House and Senate budget writers, for the most part, ignored all of Obama’s big ideas when drafting their fiscal plans, sapping his agenda ofmomentum.