House, Senate poised to adopt Obama budget

Published



The House and Senate slogged their way toward passing budgets that broadly endorse President Barack Obama’s agenda for education, health care and clean energy but delay difficult decisions on the deficit.

Obama’s Senate allies on Thursday voted down an alternative plan by Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., to boost the Pentagon budget and spare wealthier Americans from paying higher taxes.

Democrats in the House were poised to reject a GOP plan calling for major tax cuts, a radical overhaul of Medicare and rolling back Obama’s economic stimulus program, including the second year of the $400 tax credit for most workers that just went into effect on Wednesday.

The plan offered by McCain, Obama’s White House opponent last fall, would have curbed the growth of benefit programs like Medicare and capped domestic agency budgets. The Republican sought to eliminate Obama’s proposed increases in taxes on people earning more than $200,000 and couples making more than $250,000. The Senate voted 60-38 to kill McCain’s amendment.

Passage of the underlying Democratic plans would provide the young administration with a symbolic boost, even though the budget blueprints provide little guidance on how to craft subsequent Obama initiatives to reshape the health care system or combat global warming.

The Senate voted on about two dozen amendments to the nonbinding budget plan. It voted to call upon Congress to pass a law requiring the Federal Reserve to reveal the names of the banks and other financial institutions it has lent money to since a crisis hit the financial system last year. It also sought to make it more difficult to increase energy prices or make worse the so-called marriage penalty that taxes married couples more than if they had filed as individuals.

Republicans in both chambers put forward alternatives that are more generous with tax cuts and stingier with spending, but none of the plans — Obama’s, House and Senate Democrats.’ or the competing GOP outlines — would succeed in tamping down the deficit much below $500 billion within five years.

Congressional budget resolutions are nonbinding blueprints that set the parameters for legislation to follow. Unlike budget resolutions typically advanced in the first years of a presidency, the 2010 budget plans are remarkably light on detail, offering little guidance on how to pay for a health care overhaul or an extension of Obama’s signature $400 tax credit for most workers.

Much of the debate has centered on how to deal with mammoth deficits and what should be done about them. To a considerable degree, however, both parties are paying little heed to the deficit as they advance their respective agendas.

“Our budget reduces the deficit, cuts taxes for middle class families, and makes critical investments in health care, education and clean energy,” Rep. Jim McGovern, D-Mass., said Thursday.

Neither Obama nor his Democratic allies made major revisions in light of the worsening deficit picture, though Senate Budget Committee Chairman Kent Conrad, D-N.D., pressed to roll back some of Obama’s increases for domestic programs. In 2010, for example, the Senate budget plan would pare $15 billion from nondefense accounts, which still would leave increases averaging 7 percent.

Those curbs barely dent a deficit projected at $1.2 trillion for the next year. Deficits remain high despite tighter restraint on spending growth in subsequent years.

“The President’s budget shows deficits averaging $600 billion a year even after the economy recovers from the recession and even after our troops come home from Iraq,” said Rep. Jerry Lewis, R-Calif. “That’s not good enough.”

The most contentious question facing Democratic negotiators responsible for reconciling the differing House and Senate versions is whether to use the measures as a precursor to advancing health care legislation under rules that would allow the compromise bill to pass the Senate by a simple majority after just 20 hours of debate.

As a general rule, debate is freewheeling in the Senate and most bills need 60 votes to advance, guaranteeing that the minority party has leverage.

Seeking the upper hand over Senate Republicans, House leaders are insisting on having a filibuster-proof bill at the ready if bipartisan efforts to pass health care fall apart. That effort is being resisted by the Senate, though it seems increasingly clear that the final House-Senate compromise on the budget is likely to allow health care reform to pass on a fast track.