Should women have to register for the draft? They may be forced to soon

Published



On Dec. 3, 2015, all gender-based restrictions on military service were revoked. This decision finally allowed women to be able to serve on the front lines. Defense Secretary Ashton Carter announced, “They’ll be allowed to drive tanks, fire mortars, and lead infantry soldiers into combat. They’ll be able to serve as Army Rangers and Green Berets, Navy SEALs, Marine Corps infantry, Air Force parajumpers and everything else that was previously open only to men.”

After decades of baby steps gradually inching women towards the front lines of military operations, many considered Carter’s decision to open all military roles to women a huge step forward. Of course, opposition has also risen against the decision.

Some people worry that allowing women to fight on the front lines of battle will weaken the military, as they believe that women are both physically and mentally weaker than men. Supporters of the decision, argue that women are just as capable as men and that all Americans, regardless of gender, should have the opportunity to serve their country.

This decision to allow women to serve on the front lines raises the question: should women be required to register with the Selective Service? In the past, the Supreme Court has ruled that women should not be required to register. In the 1980 case, Rostker v. Goldberg, the Supreme Court ruled that excluding women from registration was not gender-based discrimination and constitutional, due to the fact that at that time, women were excluded from combat. However, now that women can serve in combat, the Supreme Court’s ruling would no longer be valid.

As the draft age range for men is 18- to 25-years-old, drafting is an issue that is likely to affect millennials, whether it is themselves, a brother, a son, a friend, or a boyfriend being called to duty. In the future, it could also be a sister, daughter, or girlfriend.

Many millennials agree that women should be required to register for the draft, though their reasons for this belief vary.

“Women not only want to be in the military but even infantry, so why shouldn’t they be given the opportunity?” asked young U.S. Marine Lance Corporal Koenig. “This country is everyone’s to protect,” he added. However, Koenig said that men should be the first to be drafted, because, “Someone has to stay behind to enjoy the freedom.”

John Uptergrove, a high school senior from Portland, Texas, had a similar sentiment.

“Personally, I think only one member of a family should be required to register,” he said. “For example, if a man and woman have a child, then it should be up to them to decide who goes. I believe one should at least be able to stay at home to continue the family in case the other dies in combat.”

Brittany Brandenburg, a sonar technician in the U.S. navy, acknowledged that not all women are cut out for the infantry.

“While there are several women who are physically able to try for these combat positions, I am also aware that a large percent of women in the United States are not as mentally or physically prepared to serve in a war,” she said. “While forcing all women to register for selective service may be fair, I don’t think it would be tactically wise.” However, Brandenburg also believes that “any able-bodied person” should step up to serve his or her country in a time of need.

While it seems that the majority of millennials agree that women should be required to register with the Selective Service, there is certainly a number of those who strongly believe that women should not be drafted.

Adam Coughlin, a twenty-year-old Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) in the U.S. Air Force, argued that women should not be on the ground. “The standards for women in the military are way lower than the standards for men, meaning people who are going to provide subpar work are going to make it in. Say I get shot or blown up by an IED. How is that female going to be able to drag me to cover or carry me to safety?”

Most likely, this question will not be answered until there is a crisis on our hands. Given the Supreme Court’s previous ruling combined with the new decision to allow women to serve in combat roles, it seems likely that sooner or later women will be drafted and sent to war, as their fellow male citizens have been for centuries.