Facebook promises not to experiment with ‘I Voted’ tool this year

Published November 3, 2014 8:25pm ET



Facebook has repented from their guinea-pig-creating ways, and will not be experimenting on the public with their “I Voted” tool this year, Mother Jones reported.

In past years, Facebook has manipulated various aspects of their feed and the “I Voted” tool to gauge how users would respond.

Mother Jones took a detailed look at these manipulations. With various users, Facebook tweaked versions of the “I Voted” tool, placing it in different locations, and phrasing it it in different ways: “I’m a Voter,” for example, or “I’m Voting.” Meanwhile, they withheld friends’ “I Voted” statuses from some users.

A review of the experiment found that 20 percent of users reported voting if they had seen that their friends voted, while 18 percent reported voting if they had not seen anything about their friends’ voting.

And in yet another experiment , Facebook promoted any news story shared by a friend to the top of users’ page. They found that this increased the number of occasional Facebook users who voted from 64 percent to 67 percent.

 

Mother Jones describes the stunning results:

After the election, the study’s authors examined voter records and concluded that Facebook’s nudging had increased voter turnout by at least 340,000. As the study noted, that’s about 0.14 percent of the total voting-age population in 2010. Considering that overall turnout rose from 37.2 percent in 2006 to 37.8 percent in 2010—both off-year, nonpresidential elections—the Facebook scientists maintained that the voter megaphone impact in 2010 was substantial. “It is possible,” the Facebook team wrote in Nature, “that more of the 0.6 percent growth in turnout between 2006 and 2010 might have been caused by a single message on Facebook.”

Of course, some of these numbers are dubious, as they come from self-reported voters.

Another key takeaway from Mother Jones’ piece: if Facebook did indeed help increase voter turnout in past elections, they likely benefited Democrats, since Facebook users skew young and female.