In his rant for Salon, David Palumbo-Liu is ready to lecture us on the “reasonable” demands of student protesters. Readers are in for a treat from the start, with the title of “Quit assuming students protesting racism are spoiled whiners!”
Palumbo-Liu begins his piece by throwing out various terms used to describe students:
Recommended Stories
Do these terms actually make it a problem for “seriously addressing the issues being raised?” Or do the student protesters carry some of the blame as well?
Students are “coddled” when university administrators cater to their whims, with many of them being so focused on a sense of being “politically correct.” Many of them are “spoiled” in how they demand to get their way, and many of them are indeed “terrifying” as they interrupt administrators, shout, spit, and even curse at them. And, you don’t have to be a conservative professor to not like such treatment.
From start to finish, many of Palumbo-Liu’s points can be rebutted by pointing out the issue many see with the methods these student protesters employ.
Palumbo-Liu does not address the methods, but rather focuses on the demands. The piece points to the top 13 demands from “students protesting racism” at 51 colleges. Palumbo-Liu highlights the top two, “increase diversity of professors” and “require diversity training.”
Palumbo-Liu writes that “it’s worth noting…that many faculty and some administrators are in favor of these top two demands.” He also suggests that “the issue of censorship has been grossly inflated,” to ask “what is so troubling about the real core of the demands?”
Except has “the issue of censorship…been grossly inflated?” Even if there is support for the demands, at least the top two, it’s a troubling concern that students may claim to support free speech, yet come out against it if it may offend minorities. Many also take issue with the methods student protesters take.
When it comes to the top demand, it’s worth suggesting that professors are hired more so on merit, rather than on the color of his or her skin.
Palumbo-Liu also offers his own ideas of what the point of school is when writing, one of which includes “to facilitate upward mobility and increase inclusion of underrepresented minority populations — to, indeed, democratize society.”
Student protesters and their supporters like Palumbo-Liu think of the protesters, and only them. The point of a college is to get an education, which ought to be free from racism, certainly. But, racism is not the only issue which negatively affects the ability to learn. It’s difficult for students, minority or not, to get an education when students disrupt their classes with protests.
Palumbo-Liu raises and then denounces the common criticism against the other top demand, training, that it’s “for the sake of protecting students from ‘the real world.'” Even if it’s not the point of it, it is a consequence, for “the real world” operates differently from what college campuses have become.
A suggestion is made to “look at it also in terms of sheer pragmatics: Listening seriously to these demands is a necessary step toward creating what I have called ‘the new effective classroom.'” If only that were the case. If students want their demands to be seriously listened to, they have to cooperate with administrators.
Palumbo-Liu is also too kind to student protesters when he claims that “students are simply asking for the resources we all need to make these conversations both honest and meaningful.”
As Salon pieces are wont to do, Palumbo-Liu closes his piece by addressing those who are “right wing.” An,d when it comes to how “the mainstream media insists on publishing and foregrounding clickbait articles,” Salon needs only look in the mirror. Palumbo-Liu does express dismay at how it’s “curious…the way liberal types are making themselves allies of the right on this issue.” Yes, perhaps because it’s an issue that transcends political preference, and the students are not as easily defendable as they are in Palumbo-Liu’s mind.