Few things divide Republicans more effectively than questions of local versus federal rulemaking and whether Washington should dictate the rules of the road to states. This is just as true for cultural issues as it is for regulating industry, and the rise of artificial intelligence has presented a unique challenge here. The recent decision by the Senate to remove the temporary pause on state AI regulations from the “One Big Beautiful Bill” is a mistake that will ultimately harm American consumers and businesses. While its fate in the budget bill is sealed, Congress still has an opportunity to take action on a federal AI plan that sets America up for success.
The concept behind the moratorium was simple yet profound: allow the maturation of AI technology without an immediate, potentially stifling, cascade of state-level regulations. Federalism and the principle of states’ rights don’t mean the states have carte blanche to regulate on any given topic. AI is a general-purpose technology that flows seamlessly across state lines to Americans, just as it does with the internet and digital commerce.