Restoring America

Conservative values, National renewal

Supreme Court rules: Individual rights trump bureaucratic efficiency

Published



Large, overweening bureaucracies don’t mix well with individual rights. Not only are people too often stunned by governmental intrusion into their personal lives, but bureaucrats regularly cut constitutional corners to make it easier to intrude. Fortunately, in several recent decisions, the Supreme Court found that administrative ease never justifies a disregard for fundamental individual rights.

At the end of its most recent term in late June, the court decided Mahmoud v. Montgomery County Public Schools. There, parents of Muslim, Catholic, Ethiopian Orthodox, and other religious faiths challenged the decision by the Montgomery County, Maryland, board of education to make mandatory a new “inclusivity” storybook series, featuring pride parades, gender transitioning, preferred pronouns, same-sex romance, and other LGBT topics. The parents argued that forcing their elementary schoolchildren to participate in the series violated their First Amendment right to raise the children in their families’ religious faiths.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.