The Supreme Court faces a fateful decision in Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder County. If it declines to take up the case and fails to slam the door on Boulder County’s audacious climate change lawsuit, the climate litigation free-for-all that will follow could cripple American energy and critically undermine our federal system.
After law school, I was a clerk for a federal circuit judge. One day, as a lawyer droned on about some statute, one of the judges on the panel finally leaned forward and drawled, “Counsel, you do realize the biggest obstacle to you winning this case is the complete absurdity of your argument.” That moment sticks with me, because when a legal doctrine leads to absurd results and a more sensible result is readily available, courts grown-up enough to read the Constitution usually reject it.