Congress is moving to restrict large investors who are already spending billions rehabilitating distressed homes, while proposing a small federal pilot program to do the same thing less efficiently. This troubling contradiction sits at the heart of the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act.
Our new research on the role of large institutional investors in single-family housing helps explain why this approach is flawed. Using detailed property-level data from Amherst Holdings — one of the largest investors in this space — we find that these firms are not primarily competing with first-time homebuyers for move-in ready homes. Instead, they systematically target properties in below-average condition within their neighborhoods, often homes with deferred maintenance or physical deterioration.