In a surprise ruling, Judge Mark Pittman of the Northern District of Texas struck down President Joe Biden’s loan forgiveness program. The ruling provides validation to those who have raised objections about its legality (to say nothing of its acute unfairness). While the Biden administration has already appealed the decision, and it’s likely to be overturned, here’s the judge’s reasoning behind the ruling:
1. The Department of Education is clearly inventing a major new authority that Congress did not intend. The HEROES Act is the justification the Biden administration used when directing the Department of Education to forgive loans. The 9/11-era law allows the Department to “waive or modify” loan provisions in a “national emergency.” However, the judge notes that the law “does not mention loan forgiveness” and instead seems to contemplate temporary flexibilities. In the ruling, Judge Pittman states the obvious:
…the executive branch unconstitutionally exercises “legislative powers” vested in Congress. In this case, the HEROES Act—a law to provide loan assistance to military personnel defending our nation—does not provide the executive branch clear congressional authorization to create a $400 billion student loan forgiveness program.The judge liberally cites the Supreme Court’s ruling from earlier this year in West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency, which took steps to rein in federal agencies’ discretion to make major policy without Congress. Pittman quotes Justice Gorsuch: