There is a great confusion plaguing American politics today: What does conservatism stand for? The label is ubiquitous, yet its substance grows increasingly elusive. We debate endlessly about policy outcomes while neglecting a far more fundamental question: By what standard do we judge whether a policy is truly conservative?
This question matters because conservatism, properly understood, is not a mood, party affiliation, or identity. It is a framework of reasoning, a set of enduring first principles that guide judgment. Without these principles, “conservative policy” becomes whatever happens to be popular on the Right at a given moment. When that occurs, conservatism loses both coherence and credibility.