I wanted to dislike Vice President JD Vance’s Communion. For years, he has championed a populist movement whose online culture too often mistakes cruelty for wit and provocation for courage. Before his 2022 Senate run, I admired Hillbilly Elegy for highlighting ignored societal crises. But after his dismissals of political opponents as “childless cat ladies” and confrontational rhetoric regarding refugees, it became difficult to take his religious turn seriously. Yet, as a Catholic, I am bound to value grace and forgiveness. So, I decided to practice what I preach and read Communion.
Make no mistake: Communion is a political manifesto for Vance’s future. Like Hillbilly Elegy, it relies more on revelatory anecdotes than rigid policy to articulate his worldview. While Vance accurately diagnoses some of our most corrosive societal afflictions, his core premise is fundamentally flawed. He attempts to hijack Catholic social teaching to serve as the framework for what is essentially Christian Nationalism. But Catholic thought is not a black-and-white political playbook designed to endorse a nation-state; it is a universal moral guide for a broken world. This lack of nuance is where Vance and I part ways.